top of page

How Home Buyers Price a House: ARV, Offer Percentages, and the Real Cost of a Flip Explained For Homeowners who Want to Sell The House Fast

Writer: henry bretz
henry bretz
Sep 29
9 min read

Why a cash offer is lower than a listing price

A cash home buyer's offer starts from what the house will be worth after it is fixed up, then subtracts everything it costs to get there. That number is called the After Repair Value (ARV), and nearly every investor, flipper and wholesaler prices a house the same way: a percentage of ARV, minus repairs. For a home owner who wants to sell a house fast a cash offer is offten the best.

The percentage is where buyers differ. Many investors still use the old "70% rule," while others go to 80%, 81% or 82%. Henry Purchases Homes offers up to 84% of ARV minus expenses, which puts more money in the seller's pocket than most cash buyers will.

This guide walks through how buyers estimate ARV, how the percentage works, and the hidden costs that explain why no buyer can pay 100%.

What ARV is and how buyers estimate it

ARV is the price a house should sell for once it is fully repaired and updated. It is not today's value in as-is condition, and it is not the tax assessor's number.

Buyers estimate ARV from comparable sales ("comps"):

  1. Pull 3–5 recently sold homes nearby, ideally within the last 3–6 months and within about half a mile.

  2. Keep only comps that are remodeled and similar in size, bedrooms, baths, age and style.

  3. Divide each sold price by its above-grade square footage to get price per square foot.

  4. Average those figures and multiply by the subject home's above-grade square footage.

Comp

Sold price

Sq ft

$ / sq ft

456 Maple Ave

$425,000

720

$590

789 Oak Dr

$407,000

720

$565

Average



$578

A 720 sq ft subject home × $578 per sq ft gives an ARV of about $416,000. Basements are usually valued separately from above-grade space, which is why buyers use above-grade footage for this step.

ARV is an estimate, not an appraisal. If a buyer's ARV is too high, the whole offer is too high, so good buyers check comps carefully and walk the property.

The offer formula: a percentage of ARV minus repairs

Every cash buyer uses a version of this formula:

Max offer = (ARV × buyer's percentage) − repairs

The percentage is the buyer's choice, and it sets how much room they leave for loan interest, holding costs, selling costs and profit. A lower percentage means a safer deal for the buyer and less money for the seller.

Using the example home ($416,000 ARV, $75,000 in repairs), here is what each percentage means for the seller:

Buyer's % of ARV

ARV × %

Minus repairs

Offer to seller

Difference vs. 70%

70% (classic flipper rule)

$291,200

−$75,000

$216,200

—

75%

$312,000

−$75,000

$237,000

+$20,800

80%

$332,800

−$75,000

$257,800

+$41,600

81%

$336,960

−$75,000

$261,960

+$45,760

82%

$341,120

−$75,000

$266,120

+$49,920

84% (Henry Purchases Homes)

$349,440

−$75,000

$274,440

+$58,240

Each percentage point of ARV is worth about $4,160 on this house. On a $416,000 home, the gap between a 70% buyer and an 84% buyer is more than $58,000.

The repair number matters just as much. Buyers estimate it room by room: paint, flooring, kitchen, baths, HVAC, electrical, doors, exterior, windows, water heater, trash-out and basement, then round up for surprises.

Renovation cost per square foot in Denver metro

In Denver metro, renovations run roughly $15 to $60 per square foot for a light cosmetic refresh, up to $400–$700+ for a luxury gut. The level of work, not the size of the house alone, drives the number.

Caveat: these prices fluctuate wildly. Published Denver ranges for the same type of job differ by 3× or more between sources. Labor availability, material tariffs, permits, the home's age and condition, and what turns up once walls are opened can move a budget sharply up. Treat every figure here as a starting point and get contractor bids before committing.

Level of work

What it usually includes

Cost per sq ft (Denver metro)

Source

Light cosmetic

Paint, flooring, fixtures, landscaping

$15–$60

Standard flip rehab

Cosmetic work plus kitchen and bath updates

$50–$150

Comprehensive remodel

Layout changes, full mechanical updates

$200–$400

Luxury gut renovation

Down to studs, premium systems and finishes

$400–$700+

Basement finish

Framing, drywall, flooring, often a bath

$35–$150

Home addition

New foundation, framing, roof and finishes

$300–$500

Investors usually land at the low end of these ranges. They use investor-grade materials, repeat contractors and skip layout changes, while homeowner remodel quotes include retail markups and custom finishes.

Rehab cost guide: line items at 2026 Denver market prices

Each line below shows a 2026 Denver market price, set near the middle of current Denver contractor ranges. Items marked "estimate" had no current Denver source and were raised for 2026 labor and material increases, so get a bid on those. As the caveat above says, real quotes for the same job can land well above or below these numbers.

Paint and drywall

Item

Unit

Price

Basis

Interior paint

per sq ft of floor

$4.00

Denver $2–$6 (Angi)

Full exterior paint

per sq ft of floor

$3.00

$2–$4 per floor sq ft (HomeGPT)

Exterior trim only

per sq ft of floor

$1.50

Estimate

Scrape and texture ceiling

per sq ft

$2.00

Denver $1–$2 (Daeco)

Texture walls

per sq ft

$1.75

Texture adds $1–$3 (Angi)

New trim package

per sq ft of floor

$3.75

Estimate

Sheetrock room

per room

$900

Estimate

Flooring (installed)

Item

Unit

Price

Basis

Carpet

per sq ft

$5.00

Denver mid-grade $4–$6 (Denver Dream Builders)

Tile

per sq ft

$15.00

Denver $9–$20 (Angi)

Solid wood

per sq ft

$14.00

Denver $10–$22 (Denver Dream Builders)

Engineered wood / LVP

per sq ft

$6.00

Denver LVP $5–$12 (Denver Carpet & Flooring)

Refinish wood floors

per sq ft

$4.50

Denver $3–$8 (JR Hardwood)

Kitchen (scaled to ARV)

Home's ARV

Kitchen price

Under $300,000

$15,000

$300,000–$399,999

$18,000

$400,000–$499,999

$22,000

$500,000–$699,999

$26,000

$700,000–$899,999

$35,000

$900,000–$1,099,999

$50,000

$1,100,000 and up

$75,000

Denver budget kitchens run about $12,000–$15,000 and minor remodels $15,000–$30,000 (RenovCost, KBD Colorado). Imported cabinets and vanities still carry a 25% tariff.

Baths

Item

Unit

Price

Basis

Basic bath

each

$12,000

Denver basic remodel $12,000–$20,000 (Frontier Design)

5-piece master

each

$22,000

Denver mid-range $20,000–$35,000 (Frontier Design)

Create new master

each

$28,000

Estimate: mid-range bath plus new plumbing

Half bath – light update

each

$1,000

Estimate

Half bath – full update

each

$6,000

Denver cosmetic refresh from $5,000 (Frontier Design)

Master bath (ARV $800k+)

each

$40,000

Denver high-end $35,000–$60,000 (Frontier Design)

HVAC

Item

Unit

Price

Basis

Condenser (A/C)

each

$6,500

Denver $3,300–$10,400 (Angi, HVAC Project Cost)

Furnace

each

$6,500

Denver $4,700–$8,450 (Costadia)

New system (furnace + A/C)

each

$13,000

Denver $8,000–$17,000 (HVAC Project Cost)

Swamp cooler

each

$2,000

Estimate

Electrical

Item

Unit

Price

Basis

Fixture package

per sq ft of floor

$2.25

Estimate

Can lights

each

$275

Estimate

Update two-prong plugs

per house

$3,500

Estimate

New exterior panel (200A)

each

$5,500

Denver $4,000–$7,500 (Over-All Electric)

Move interior panel outside

each

$7,500

Estimate: full upgrade plus relocation

Re-wire

per sq ft of floor

$8.00

$6–$10 with walls opened (HomeAdvisor)

Doors

Item

Unit

Price

Basis

Interior door

each

$300

Estimate

Exterior door

each

$800

Estimate

Front door – basic

each

$1,000

Estimate

Front door – upgraded

each

$2,000

Estimate

French door set

each

$3,000

Estimate

Garage door

per car

$1,800

Estimate

Exterior

Item

Unit

Price

Basis

Roof

per sq ft of floor

$10.00

Asphalt $6.73 per sq ft of roof, about 1.3 sq ft of roof per sq ft of floor (Instant Roofer)

Siding

per side

$3,500

Colorado vinyl $9–$18 per sq ft of wall (Excel Roofing)

Landscape package

each

$3,500

Estimate

Tree trimming

per tree

$450

Estimate

Fence (wood privacy)

per linear ft

$32

Colorado wood privacy $15–$35 (CostFlow)

Basic 2-car garage with pad

each

$40,000

Estimate: get a bid

Concrete

per sq ft

$12.00

Denver driveway $8–$20 (Angi)

Miscellaneous

Item

Unit

Price

Basis

Windows (vinyl, Energy Star)

each

$700

Denver vinyl $450–$850 (Window Replacement Denver)

Water heater

each

$2,500

Denver $1,700–$4,000 (Design Transition Studio)

Trash out

per dumpster

$1,400

Estimate

Foundation

bid

Bid

Always get an engineer's bid

Move laundry room

each

$3,500

Estimate

Basement

Item

Unit

Price

Basis

Finish unfinished basement

per basement sq ft

$45.00

Denver budget finish $35–$65 (Apollo Renovation)

Update finished basement

per basement sq ft

$15.00

Estimate

Add 3/4 bath

each

$18,000

Estimate: basic bath plus new plumbing

Add egress – unfinished basement

each

$4,500

Denver $3,050–$5,820 (Angi)

Add egress – finished basement

each

$5,500

Denver $4,000–$7,500 (CountBricks)

At these market prices, the example home's scope comes to about $128,000. Most of that is the three bathrooms, where retail Denver prices run high.

Why small houses cost more per square foot

The example home's $75,000 rehab works out to about $104 per square foot on 720 sq ft. A kitchen, bathroom and water heater cost about the same in a small house as in a large one, so those fixed costs push the per-foot figure up. The same scope on a 1,500 sq ft home would come out closer to $60–$70 per square foot.

The hidden costs that come out of the percentage

Repairs are only part of the cost of a flip. Everything below is paid out of the gap between the offer and the ARV, which is why no buyer can offer 100%.

Cost

Typical assumption

Why it is high

Renovation loan interest

12% per year on purchase + repairs

Flips are funded with short-term hard-money loans, which cost far more than a 30-year mortgage and often add 1–3 points up front

Holding period

About 6 months

Closing, permits, contractor schedules, repairs, listing and the buyer's own closing all take time

Taxes, insurance and utilities

About $650 per month

A vacant home still needs insurance, heat, power and water, and taxes keep accruing

Purchase closing and title

About 1.5% of purchase price

Title insurance, escrow and lender fees on the way in

Agent commissions to resell

About 5.5% of ARV

The finished house is usually listed on the open market

Resale closing and concessions

About 1.5% of ARV

Seller-paid closing costs, inspection credits and buyer requests

Surprises

Rounded into repairs

Foundation, sewer lines, wiring, mold and permit issues often appear only after walls open

Cost assumptions above are the defaults in the offer calculator used for this guide. Actual rates vary by lender, market and property.

Carrying costs compound: every extra month adds interest, taxes, insurance and utilities. A three-month delay on a single project can erase a thin margin entirely.

A full cost breakdown of one flip

At 84% of ARV, the buyer of the example home keeps about $8,500, roughly 2% of the sale price. Here is where the $416,000 goes:

Line item

Amount

After repair value (sale price)

$416,000

Paid to seller (84% × ARV − repairs)

−$274,440

Repairs

−$75,000

Purchase closing and title (1.5%)

−$4,117

Loan interest, 12% for 6 months

−$20,966

Taxes, insurance and utilities, 6 months

−$3,900

Agent commissions to resell (5.5%)

−$22,880

Resale closing and concessions (1.5%)

−$6,240

Left for buyer's profit and risk

$8,457

The percentage a buyer chooses is really a choice about how much of that last line to keep:

Buyer's % of ARV

Offer to seller

Buyer's estimated profit

Profit as % of ARV

70%

$216,200

$71,065

17.1%

75%

$237,000

$48,705

11.7%

80%

$257,800

$26,345

6.3%

82%

$266,120

$17,401

4.2%

84%

$274,440

$8,457

2.0%

Higher percentages move money from the buyer to the seller. They also leave the buyer less cushion if repairs run over or the house takes longer to sell.

Henry Purchases Homes: up to 84% of ARV minus expenses

Henry Purchases Homes offers up to 84% of ARV minus repairs, one of the highest percentages among cash home buyers. On the example home, that is $58,240 more than a 70% offer and $8,320 more than an 82% offer.

The percentage is set by the home's ARV:

ARV

Percentage offered

Under $600,000

84%

$600,000 – $699,999

83%

$700,000 – $799,999

82%

$800,000 – $899,999

81%

$900,000 and up

80%

Every offer comes with a written breakdown: the comps behind the ARV, the repair estimate line by line, and the costs to buy, hold and resell. Sellers can check each number instead of taking a single figure on faith.

What sellers get with a Henry Purchases Homes offer:

  • A cash offer on the house as-is, with no repairs or cleaning

  • No agent commissions paid by the seller

  • A closing date the seller chooses

How to compare cash offers

  • Ask each buyer what ARV they used and which comps support it

  • Ask what percentage of ARV they offer

  • Ask for the repair estimate, line by line

  • Compare the final cash-to-seller number, not only the headline percentage

  • Confirm who pays closing costs and whether there are any fees deducted at closing

  • Check proof of funds and how fast they can close

Frequently asked questions

Why doesn't a cash buyer pay full market value? The buyer pays for repairs, a high-interest renovation loan, months of holding costs, and about 7% in selling costs before earning anything.

Is the 70% rule still standard? Many flippers still use it because it leaves a wide safety margin. Buyers with lower costs can offer 80% or more.

Does a higher percentage always mean a better offer? Usually, but only if the ARV and repair numbers are honest. A high percentage on a low ARV, or with inflated repairs, can come out lower.

Can I sell as-is? Yes. The repair estimate is already subtracted from the offer, so the seller does not fix anything first.

Figures in this guide are estimates for illustration, not an appraisal. Actual ARV, repair and resale costs vary by property.


Writen by Henry Bretz 9/29/2026

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page